The Multicultural State: Progress or Tragedy?

Abstract

This essay is a short response to Daniel Bonilla Maldonado’s contribution, »Beyond the State: Can State Law Survive in the Twenty-First Century?« to the recently published Cambridge History of Latin American Law in Global Perspective. While Bonilla sees progress in the movement from the centralized nation-state to the multicultural state, my essay argues for an appreciation of the values that motivated the creation of the unified state as a single constitutional order in the post-colonial period. This effort may have failed, but with that failure went a distinct and valuable idea of freedom.